At Pinehearst, Peter hovers over his father's dead body. Peter tells Nathan that Sylar killed Arthur. Nathan says that he has a dozen marines in the building. Nathan says that he wants to continue on with Arthur's plan to make the world a better place by giving people abilities. Nathan says that he is going to finish what his father started. Peter raises his gun at Nathan. Nathan asks him to join his quest. Peter knocks out Nathan then leaves.

At Primatech, Noah, Meredith, Claire and Angela load up with weapons to fight with Arthur. They notice that the security guards in the building are dead. Sylar gets on the intercom and says that Arthur is dead. Using his mind, Sylar locks up all of the windows and doors. Sylar says that he will prove that they are all monsters. Claire tells them that Sylar has a weak spot in his brain. Sylar tells Claire that they are similar in which both of them can not be hurt. Meredith and Sylar team up to try to find Sylar. They go into the security room and see that Sylar is not there. Sylar tells Noah that he is hunting him.

Ando, Matt and Daphne go to Suresh's lab to try to get the formula in order to give Ando the ability to go back in time. They find that he is not there. Daphne says that Suresh is probably at Pinehearst. Daphne uses her speed to run to Suresh.

Suresh is about to inject himself with the formula. Peter arrives, points a gun at Suresh and tells him to drop the syringe. Daphne speeds by and takes the syringe. Flint and Knox arrive and grab Suresh. Flint says that they want to stop Suresh because they will no longer be special if everyone has powers. Peter helps them destroy the lab. Later, Flint knocks out Suresh then helps wreck the lab. Knox exits the lab, finds a marine talking to Nathan, then breaks the marine's neck. Knox tells Nathan that Peter is working with him now.

Daphne returns to Ando and Matt. Daphne gives Ando the syringe with the formula. Ando injects himself, then collapses.

16 years in the past, Hiro pushes his way back to the balcony from the light pole that he was thrown to by Arthur. He enters his father's apartment and sees that his younger self is sad that his mom is gone. Hiro asks young Hiro for his father's formula.

At Primatech, Claire tries to make a call to the outside world, but finds that the line has been cut. Angela says that Sylar is starving for attention. The phone rings and Claire picks it up and puts it on speaker phone. Sylar tells Claire to shoot Angela in exchange for her and her father's life. Claire says that she will kill him if he hurts her father. Sylar says that her anger shows that she has become a monster. Clarie takes a shotgun, pumps it, then shoots the phone.

Noah releases the level 5 prisoners and tells them to hunt down Sylar. Meredith realizes that Noah is using them as bait.

Matt and Daphne wake up Ando who later tries to jump back in time. Ando fails, gets angry and sees a red energy emit form his hand. Matt says that he doesn't think that he has time travel abilities.